[University home]

School of Environment and Development

Conferences

Logos of BWPI, GPRG and ESRC

POVERTY AND CAPITAL

Global Poverty Research Group and
Brooks World Poverty Institute Conference
held at Hulme Hall, University of Manchester

2 – 4 July 2007

Programme

You will need a PDF reader such as Adobe Acrobat (downloadable from Adobe) to view PDF file(s). PDF files open in a new window.

Papers

Development Finance: Challenges and the Way Forward,
Tony Addison and Thankom Arun.

Rethinking Collectivities: Institutional Innovations in Common Property Management and Group Farming,
Bina Agarwal.

Opportunities’ for the Poor, Co-responsibilities for Women: the Implications of Managerial Models of Poverty Reduction for Female Survival Strategies (PDF 90KB), 
Alejandro Agudo-Sanchíz.

Paradoxes of Global Capitalism in Small Developing Countries: Lessons from Costa Rica,
Diego Sánchez Ancochea.

Multinational Companies in Low-Income Markets: an Analysis of Social Embeddedness in Southeast Asia,
Dina Badry.

Mining and Social Movements: Struggles over Livelihood and Rural Territorial Development in the Andes (PDF 300KB),
Anthony Bebbington.

Capitalism and Moral Economy: Land Questions in sub-Saharan Africa (PDF 165KB) ,
Henry Bernstein.

Debt Relief and the Private Sector in Africa (PDF 65KB),
Lobna Bousrih and Sana Harrabi.

Bitter Fruit:  Development and Destitution
Vigdis Broch-Due.

Protected Areas, Displacement and the Power of Virtualism Conservation in a Neoliberal Age,
Dan Brockington and Jim Igoe.

The Political Ecology of Water and the Neoliberal Project in Chile,
Jessica Budds.

The Global Commodity Chain in Canned Tuna, Trade Preferences and Industrial Upgrading: the Rise and Demise of Tuna Processing in ACP Countries,
Liam Campling.

Lazy Japanese and Thieving Germans: Culture, Poverty and Economic Development (PDF 75KB),
Ha-Joon Chang.

Taking a Long Term View: Land as Capital and the Intergenerational Transmission of Chronic Poverty in Windhoek,
Admos Chimhowu.

A Critique of the Orthodox Approach to Indonesia's Growth and Employment Problems and Keynesian Alternatives,
Anis Chowdhury and Iyanatul Islam.

Economic Clusters or Cultural Commons? The Limits of Competition-Driven Development in Two Andean Textile Towns (PDF 100KB),
Rudi Colloredo-Mansfeld and Jason Antrosio.

Privatisation of Electricity and Water - Is it still worthwhile? (PDF 120KB),
Hulya Dagdeviren.

New Forms of Urban Poverty in the Informal Sector: a Case Study from the Urban Slums in Istanbul, Turkey,
Demet Dinler.

Corruption and Privatisation: Some New Insights into the Distribution of Income in Latin America,
Carlyn Dobson.

Helping Hand Instead of Handouts: Social Safety Net Provision by the Grameen Bank (PDF 115KB),
Asif Dowla.

Neoliberalising Nature? Conservation, Ecotourism and Community Based Natural Resource Management,
Rosaleen Duffy.

Microenterprise, Entrepreneurialism and Inequality: the Case of Tourism Development in Central America (PDF 140KB),
Lucy Ferguson.

Inequality of Opportunity and Economic Development in Latin America,
Francisco Ferreira.

Financialisation, Poverty and Marxist Political Economy (130KB),
Ben Fine.

Subsistence as Freedom: Towards an Understanding of the ‘Micro Foundations’ of Double Movements, viewed through ‘Peasants’ and Peripheries,
Andrew Fischer.

Dangerous Freedoms: Exposure to Markets and the Need for Protective Institutions in Development (PDF 120KB),
Vincent Fitzsimons.

Spiritual Poverty and Capabilities,
James Foster.

Capital, Poverty, Environmental Crisis and the New Enlightenment (PDF 90KB),
Clive George.

The New International Division of Labour and the Differentiated Evolution of Poverty at World Scale (PDF 140KB),
Nicolas Grinberg.

Poverty and Capitalism (PDF 80KB),
Barbara Harriss-White.

Antinomies of Development in a Global-Asian Era,
Jeff Henderson, Khalid Nadvi and Nicola Phillips.

Contesting Unfair International Capitalism: Self-Assessment of the Effectiveness and Impact of Campaigning and Advocacy from the NGO Sector (PDF 165KB),
Leonith Hinojosa, Edward Egan, John Logan, Maurice Kirk, Dave Pierce and Chris Worral

Turning the Tide: Re-Evaluating Codetermination in the Chinese Context,
Cecily Hurst.

Self-Help Initiatives: Reconciling Capitalist Self-Interest with Islamic Agency (PDF 250KB),
Solava Ibrahim.

China’s Impact on Latin America: the Trade Dimensions,
Rhys Jenkins.

The Role of Markets in the Construction of Wellbeing: the Need for a Polanyian Perspective (PDF 66KB),
Susan Johnson.

Do the Asian Drivers Undermine Export-Oriented Industrialisation in sub-Saharan Africa and with what Impact on Poverty?
Raphael Kaplinsky.

Assessing the Poverty Impact of Trade Liberalisation: a Critical Appraisal of the Computable General Equilibrium Approach,
Colin Kirkpatrick and Serban Scrieciu.

Local Production and Global Consumption,
Uma Kothari.

Coordination and Motivation in Firms: Common Goods and Conflicting Interests (PDF 90KB),
Helena Lopes.

Marginalisation and Globalisation: a Case Study of Women Workers in Kerala,
Nikhila Menon.

Global Power Shifts - Impacts on ‘North-South Relationships’,
Dirk Messner.

What is Global Inequality and Why it Matters (PDF 960KB),
Branco Milanovic.

Adaptation, Subjective Well-Being and Poverty – the Case of Drought in South India,
Daniel Neff.

Informal Agricultural Work, Habitus and Practices in an Indian Context (PDF 260KB),
Daniel Neff and Wendy Olsen.

Poverty Reduction versus Growth Modelling: Methods and Results
Hisako Nomura and Wendy Olsen.

Moral Political Economy and Poverty in Rural India:  Four Theoretical Schools Compared (PDF 380KB),
Wendy Olsen.

The Future of the Profits-Investment-Growth Nexus,
Jonathan Perraton.

Utilitarianism, ‘Adaptation’ and Paternalism (PDF 72KB),
Mozaffar Qizilbash.

Microfinance – a Local Concept to Global Movement to Noble Peace Prize: Future Challenges and Opportunities,
Aminur Rahman.

The Implications of the ADB Loan on the Indian State of Kerala,
K Ravi Raman.

Class Adaptation and Adaptability in India: a Case Study of Migrant Workers,
Bheem Reddy and Wendy Olsen.

‘They Own this Land. It’s not up to the State to Decide Whom they Sell their Rights to.’ Indigenous Rights and Capitalist Development in the Ecuadorian Amazon,
Laura Rival.

Exploring the meaning of consumption through expenditure and motives in a Peruvian corridor, (PDF 341KB),
Monica Guillen Royo.

Development Finance as an Instrument of Poverty Reduction - Outcome of two Distinct Phases in India, (PDF 113KB),
P Satish.

Building Inclusive Financial Services and Poverty Reduction in Tanzania,
Tadeo Andrew Satta.

Inequality Persistence and Institutional Development ,
Antonio Savoia and Joshy Easaw.

Poverty, global inequality and sustainability: A critical evaluation of Marxist and Green perspectives (PDF 45KB) ,
Pritam Singh.

Socio-Economic and Environmental Impacts of Land Commoditisation in Romania: the Role of Institutions,
Lindsay Stringer and Serban Scrieciu.

Capitalist Crises, Social Capital and the Distribution of Well-Being (PDF 140KB),
Gindo Tampubolon.

Poverty Alleviation as Social Policy: the World Bank’s Social Policy Agenda in Turkey,
Özlem Tastan.

Capitalist Development and the Spectre of Poverty,
John Toye.

Stakeholder Capitalism: Panacea or Problematic Pretender? (PDF 98KB),
Katherine Trebeck.

The Transformation Process of Microfinance Institutions: Beneficial for the Poor? (PDF 170KB),
Annabel Vanroose.

International Electric Distribution Cooperatives - a Public Policy Alternate: Putting Power into the Hands of a Civil Society,
R Craig Williams.

Reproducing an Unequal Security: Peru as a Wellbeing Regime,
Geof Wood and James Copestake.

Interpreting African ‘Land Markets’,
Philip Woodhouse and Jean-Philippe Colin.

Subjective Wellbeing and Development in Peru: an Empirical Approach,
Jorge Yamamoto and James Copestake.

Keynote Speakers included:

Ha-Joon Chang, University of Cambridge, UK.
Francisco Ferreira, The World Bank, USA.
Ben Fine, SOAS, University of London, UK.
Barbara Harris-White, University of Oxford, UK.
Branco Milanovic, The World Bank, USA.
John Toye, University of Oxford, UK.
Anna Tsing, University of California Santa Cruz.

The ESRC Global Poverty Research Group (GPRG) is a multidisciplinary collaboration between social scientists at the Institute for Development Policy and Management (IDPM) at the University of Manchester and economists at the Centre for the Study of African Economies at the University of Oxford. Manchester University has now consolidated its position as a leading institution for the interdisciplinary study of poverty through the establishment of the Brooks World Poverty Institute (BWPI).

GPRG research to date has highlighted the dimensions of engagement with market economies as a key issue for poor people in developing countries. The interdisciplinary challenges posed by working between economics and qualitative social sciences have also emphasised the centrality of the market paradigm for analysing social dimensions of change and assessing impacts on development. Perspectives from orthodox economics at times confront the perspectives of social science, particularly as they relate to the normativity of development models and assumptions about the links between economic growth and human wellbeing, concepts of markets and capital, and ideas about what drives positive change for the poorest.

The conference was organised around three main themes FINANCE AND ECONOMICS, CAPITALIST DEVELOPMENT and THE POLITICS AND INSTITUTIONALISATION OF CAPITALISM. The conference comprised of plenary and parallel sessions, with a full plenary for each major theme. The conference featured international speakers from across social science and economics related disciplines and participants from leading development agencies and civil society organisations. The aim was to provide an interdisciplinary space for the cross fertilisation of ideas between academics, policy makers and practitioners, and between different disciplinary takes on core processes of social transformation and economy.

CONFERENCE ADVISORY BOARD MEMBERS

Tony Addison (Professor, School of Environment and Development, University of Manchester, UK),
Paul Cammack (Professor, Politics Department, Manchester Metropolitan University, UK),
John Gledhill (Professor, School of Social Sciences, University of Manchester, UK),
Barbara Harriss-White (Director, Queen Elizabeth House, Oxford University, UK),
Stephen Kidd (Team Leader, Equity and Rights Team, DFID, UK),
Francie Lund (Associate Professor, School of Development Studies, University of KwaZuluNatal, South Africa),
Imran Matin (Director, Research and Evaluation Division, BRAC, Bangladesh),
Nancy Scheper-Hughes (Professor, Department of Anthropology, University of California Berkeley, USA),
Joseph Semboja (Executive Director, Research on Poverty Alleviation, Dar es Salaam, Tanzania),
Joseph Stiglitz (Chair, Brooks World Poverty Institute, University of Manchester, UK and IPD, Columbia University, New York, USA).

Conference Themes

1. Finance, Growth, Redistribution & Well Being

The first theme focused on the links from growth to poverty reduction, inequality and social wellbeing. It interrogated the forms of investment that accompany development processes within capitalism. How does development finance support or undermine capitalist development? What are the redistributive effects of capitalist development?

With much of the global south regularly represented as marginalised by, or marginal to, the global economy, we will explore how social relations within capitalist economy selectively produce economic and social inclusion and exclusion and the disciplinary processes which define worth and citizenship.

Is there an underlying logic to capitalist accumulation that ultimately makes mass under/unemployment and immiseration inevitable, or is globalisation already throwing up evidence of potential for structural change in the system (through national processes of resistance to TNCs and regional realignments and various kinds of reformist proposals now on the table for making the reduction of inequalities a priority)?

What capitalist instruments can enhance poverty reduction? Can trajectories of growth include the poor? Is poverty creation an inevitable by product of capitalist development?

2. Moral Economics: Commodification and Capitalist Development

Scarcity is a ruling feature of economic development under capitalism. But how is it regulated, and frugality turned into destitution? Through what processes are people incorporated into capitalist economic relationships? What social processes characterise commodification? How far can uncommodified qualities be counted within formal economic models? Do current models undervalue the assets of the poor? What are the effects of commodifcation on social relations and the environment? What is the nature of moral economies under capitalisms? How does the commodification of human capital support capitalist development? More broadly, is there a space beyond or away from capitalism viewed as a global system?

What are the prospects not only for new forms of capitalism, but new forms of organisation within a market economy framework? Is it still possible to imagine socialised forms of property and distribution that might be distinct from the kind of (state capitalism, alternative industrialism?) represented by the USSR? To what extent is it possible to imagine systems based on private property and market relationships that differ fundamentally in their distributive principles and capacity for providing dignified livelihoods from those generated by global capitalist corporations and capitalist developmentalist states.

How are work and personal security being transformed under current capitalist regimes? What are the political implications of middle class proletarianization in rich and middle income countries? How does capitalism generate wellbeing? And for whom?

3. The Politics and Institutionalisation of Capitalism

Within this theme we explored work on the structure, system and institutionalisation of capitalism. We could ask, for example, whether it is possible to distinguish the capitalism of the North Atlantic countries from other forms of capitalism (not simply institutionally–culturally–socially but as competing systems) and the extent to which the hegemonic role of the former supported by "extra-economic" geopolitical power is actually ceding to the contemporary strength and wealth of other centres of accumulation. This has ramifications for the meaning of ‘global’ and ‘multinational’, suggesting that the current global signification of the 'development agenda' and the Bretton Woods institutions could shift in significant ways in the near future, largely but not exclusively because of China, to expose an assumed universalism based in Westphalian parochialism.

If interrelated geopolitical and economic competition continue to be the essence of capitalism, then does this create spaces for new (and possibly more socially equitable) developments within a capitalist framework in the long term or will it merely be a process of relocation of centres of accumulation with undiminished social polarisation?

How is capitalism established institutionally as a mode of organisation? What is the role of the state in fostering capitalist development? How have contemporary state forms in poor countries been shaped by capitalisms? What are the politics of capitalist incorporation? What social institutions serve capitalisms in poor countries? What are the relationships between inequalities and capitalisms? How does capitalism promote or resolve conflicts? Is capitalism facilitating emerging subjectivities in its hinterlands? What are the social consequences of global capitalism in various parts of the world?

Top of page